Delicious food as always! Theyve been around for forever and there quality has never changed. They only use the highest quality ingredients. Recently theyve under gone some changes as they pass from Mother to daughter but the quality and flavor has never changed! Definitely a must try when visiting anywhere even near Indiana! 😋

We love Ahlemeyer bakery! Their staff is super sweet, talented bakers and so their baked goods are delicious!! They’ve slowly transitioned their menu to avoid animal products and I’ve shared them with folks who aren’t vegan and no one can tell. 🤗 I love that this business is inclusive and family owned. The pecan rolls are bomb - thank me later.

I was pleasantly surprised with the pies I had ordered. They are teriffic and of great quality. As far as the price I feel they were worth the $15 and more. You cant find this kind of quality.. The lady that helped me was very pleasant to me and I appreciate that. Thanks !!😊😊😊

This place is awesome! The staff was very knowledgeable and friendly about their items. They offer a huge variety of vegan options that you cant tell its vegan. Everything we bought was outstanding!

Sugar Cream pie was very good. I was pleased they were open Saturday

Nice little shop, and the staff is helpful. Small business, so pieces are a tad bigger than grocery bakeries, but are also handmade ~ we like to support local businesses when we can. Loaf size cakes or sweet bread runs $20; good selection of pies about $14 ~ dozen cookies/brownies (8 pan) $8.50.

All I can say is OMG AMAZING PIES!

Delicious coconut pie. Helpful staff.

Rude lady!!! Wouldnt allow us to shop without impeding our oxygen and freedom!!! Corona virus is fake !! Wake up, or lose business!!!

I absolutely LOVE this store! Fresh and delicious made by folks who really care and enjoy what they are doing!! HIGHLY recommend!!!

Absolutely in love with this hidden gem. Such a cozy, charming atmosphere with delectable desserts. Ill be back for sure!

Pies and cookies are outstanding.

Chocolate Kentucky Pie unfortunately sold out. But the suggested Pecan Pie absolutely made up for it. Your sweet, quality staff is almost as rich as your marvelous baked goods. Ill be back like Arnold, as quickly as possible.

Great bakery. Love the apple pie

Its a little too pricey for my liking, but you are paying for home made baked goods. I personally didnt think the pumpkin pie that we purchased was very flavorful or unique. The crust was very very bland. A Kroger pie would have tasted the same. It is great though that they can make unique orders for you! So if you are looking some a specific type of baked good, this is the place for you.

Best Bakery in the area. Pies are king/queen there, but anything they make is great.

Gotta get one of their sugar cream pies every time Im in Columbus. Its crazy good! Their pecan pie is delicious, too. Everything is made by scratch & its always fresh.

Delicious, always fresh and homemade in their kitchen!

They have the Best Baked Goods!!!

The owners are quality people and provide quality products!

Staff is ALWAYS welcoming and helpful! Always choose them when picking up a great treat for my students! Y2q

Bought a cherry pie WONDERFUL!! FINALLY fOUND A PLACE WHERE THE CRUST IS REAL THIN AND FLAKY.

Always super helpful and accommodating!! Products are delicious! Thank you Kim & Heather!

Absolutely the without a doubt best Angel food cakes but you must special order it ahead and tell them when your picking it up

Fantastic pies and friendly place!

Great cookies

Great

Friendly staff and good pies

Best pies next to grandma. Mary Shaw

They have the best pies I have ever had!!

Delicious, love the apple turnovers.

Great pies, cookies, brownies and more!! Love this place!

Overpriced. Nobakes 1 dollars each is ridiculous. 2 employees talking to each other never acknowledged me so I left. Not Customer friendly at all and no samples available

Got a coconut cream pie

Love their sugar cream pie!

Fantastic sugar cream pie !!!

Awesome place to go for pies!

Fantastic bakers and products.

Best CupCakes Ever

Ham Salad awesome

Great bakery.

Excellent!

Great pies!

I like it very much this is mat

Excellent pies

Great pies!!